Williams driver Ralf Schumacher said on Tuesday no one was to blame for a pile-up at the start of the German Grand Prix and the crash was a normal motorsport accident.

Ralf Schumacher

Appealing against a penalty imposed on him by the sport's governing body, Schumacher denied making any post-race statements admitting he displayed a lack of caution before the collision with Ferrari's Rubens Barrichello and Kimi Raikkonen of McLaren.

"It was definitely very annoying," Schumacher said. "There is no one to blame for this crash. It was a completely normal racing accident. It could have happened to anyone in any race."

Supporting Schumacher's case with film and graphics of the crash, Williams officials argued that the German was ahead of the other two drivers when the accident happened on August 3.

"The stewards decided that Barrichello and Raikkonen were not responsible at all," Andrew Hunter, Williams's barrister, told the appeals panel.

"We do not dispute that part of the decision, but the stewards must be consistent and should have concluded that this was a racing incident."

Stewards said after the race in Hockenheim that Schumacher had admitted in a brief hearing to not paying attention to the position of the other cars during his manoeuvre and penalised him for what they called an avoidable crash.

If the penalty stands, Schumacher will have to drop 10 positions from his qualifying spot at the start of his next race, the Hungarian Grand Prix on August 24.

The hearing in Paris was broadcast live on television in Germany. The decision by the ruling body, FIA, is due to be announced on Wednesday.

BLIND SPOT

Williams officials denied Schumacher made remarks to stewards saying he did not pay attention to other drivers' positions.

They said Barrichello and Raikkonen were in Schumacher's blind spot and their driver could not have seen the crash coming. He drove exactly the same line into the first corner at Hockenheim the two previous years, the team said.

But Charlie Whiting, FIA race director, countered the "blind-spot" arguments, saying drivers have lateral vision beyond side-view mirrors and must take extra care at the start.

Schumacher collided with Raikkonen and Barrichello as the three cars left the grid. Three other cars were caught up in the wake of the crash and forced to abandon the race, which was won by Colombian Juan Pablo Montoya in a Williams.

Schumacher said he felt he had been punished enough.

"Three of the favourites were out of the race all of a sudden," said Schumacher, whose chances of winning the championship were severely damaged by the crash.

Barrichello told the panel that Schumacher had crashed into him, not the other way around.

"I tried to take avoiding action," he said. "I braked and moved a little bit. I didn't drive into Ralf. He hit me."

Raikkonen, also appearing before the panel, rejected suggestions from Williams officials that he could have avoided the crash by driving on, or to the left of, the white line on the left shoulder of the track.

"I didn't want to drive off the course because that is not the best route," Raikkonen said.

Schumacher is in fourth place in the championship with 53 points, 18 behind the leader, his brother Michael Schumacher in a Ferrari. Raikkonen is in third with 62 points and Barrichello is fifth with 49.

Close

Today's Top News		Top Sports News
+Commentary: Don't meddle with yuan ( 2003-09-02) +200,000 troops to be cut by 2005 ( 2003-09-02) +Beijing Games marketing plan launched ( 2003-09-02) +Flood forces 10,0000 to evacuate ( 2003-09-02) +Beijing courts announce 50 major changes ( 2003-09-02)		+ China beat South Africa 2-0 in soccer friendly ( 2003-09-02) +Sun Jihai-Seaman mix up sends Arsenal top ( 2003-09-01) +China retains top place at world games ( 2003-09-01) +Real's Makelele completes Chelsea move ( 2003-09-01) +48-year-old Olympic champion is making a comeback ( 2003-09-01)